John
Williams'
Shadow Government Statistics
Analysis Behind and Beyond Government Economic Reporting
One Year
$175.00
Six Months
$89.00

Latest Commentaries Subscription required Subscription

PLEASE NOTE: The next Regular Commentary, Friday, December 15th, will cover November Retail Sales and Industrial Production.

No. 925: November CPI and PPI Inflation, FOMC Subscription required December 13th, 2017
• Unable to Escape 2008, FOMC Boosted Rates a Quarter-Point, Nonetheless, Amidst Fed Projections of Lower Unemployment and a Stronger GDP • Yet, Fundamentals Still Point to a Weaker Economy as Fed Chair Janet Yellen Described the Economic Outlook as "Highly Uncertain" • Prospects for U.S. Economic and Financial-Market Activity Continued to Darken; Faltering Real Consumer Credit and Earnings Do Not Support the Purported Boom • Amidst Downside Prior-Period Revisions, Fourth-Quarter 2017 Real Average Weekly Earnings Were on Track for Second Consecutive Quarterly Contraction • Monthly and Annual Jumps in CPI and PPI Were Due to Gasoline Price Swings; Headline Inflation Gains Were Not Due to Strong or Over-Heating Economic Activity • November 2017 CPI-U Monthly Inflation Jumped by 0.39% (Was 0.11%) Pulling Annual CPI-U Inflation Higher to 2.20% (Was 2.04%), with CPI-W at 2.32% (Was 2.06%) and ShadowStats at 9.9% (Was 9.8%) • November 2017 Final-Demand PPI Inflation Monthly Gain of 0.44% Pulled Annual Gain to a 70-Month High of 3.07%, versus 2.79% in October 2017 • Continuing Monthly Jump of 0.44% in November PPI was Dominated by Gain of 0.98% in Goods Inflation (4.63% Energy Gain), Versus Gain of 0.17% in Services • Inflation Will Soften November Real Retail Sales Growth versus Nominal Growth by 0.4% (-0.4%) Month-to-Month, 2.2% (-2.2%) Year-to-Year  More ...
No. 924: November Labor, Private Surveying and M3, October Trade Deficit and Construction Spending Subscription required December 8th, 2017
• Private Surveying of November Labor Conditions Showed Continuing Annual Contraction and Ongoing Non-Expansion • Still-Heavily-Distorted, November Unemployment Rates Notched Minimally Higher: U.3 Rose to 4.12% versus 4.07%, U.6 Rose to 7.96% from 7.91%, and the ShadowStats-Alternate Rose to 21.7% from 21.6% • Hurricane-Warped Unemployment and Employment Household-Survey Details Face Near-Term Corrections with the January 5th Benchmark Revisions • Low-Level Annual Payroll Growth Continued to Signal New Recession • Seasonal-Adjustment Gimmicks Bloated Headline Payroll Gains, where Unadjusted Payrolls Revised Lower but Adjusted Levels Revised Higher; Payroll-Survey Benchmark Revisions Loom for February 2nd • Fourth-Quarter 2017 Real Merchandise Trade Deficit on Early Track for Worst Showing Since First-Quarter 2007 • October 2017 Nominal Balance of Payments Trade Deficit Increased by 8.6% versus September 2017, by 13.1% versus October 2016 • Shy of Recovering Its Pre-Recession Peak by 22.0% (-22.0%), Real Construction Spending Continued in Annual Decline, as Last Seen During the 2006 Housing Collapse • Amidst Expectations of a December 13th FOMC Rate Hike, November 2017 M3 Annual Growth Eased Back to 4.6% from 4.8% in October, as Monetary-Base Annual Growth Jumped to a Four-Year High of 8.1%  More ...
No. 923: Revised Third-Quarter Gross Domestic Product (GDP), October Freight Index, New-Home Sales Subscription required November 29th, 2017
• Third-Quarter 2017 Real Per Capita Take-Home Pay (Disposable Personal Income) Contracted at an Annualized Pace of 0.29% (-0.29%) versus Second-Quarter 2017 • That Was on Top of Downside Revisions to Second-Quarter Real Disposable Income, Which Reflected More-Substantive Information from Bureau of Labor Statistics Surveying • Such Supports Neither a Booming Economy Nor a Soaring Consumer Outlook • Consumer Surveying, Driven by a Headline Faux-Economic Boom in the Press (Hurricane-Bloated Activity), Remained Strongest Since Collapsing into the 2001 Recession • Second Estimate of Real Third-Quarter 2017 GDP Revised to 3.30% (Previously 2.99%), versus 3.06% in Second-Quarter 2017 • Initial Estimate of Third-Quarter Gross National Product (GNP) at 3.47%, versus Second-Quarter at 2.77%; Third-Quarter Gross Domestic Income (GDI) at 2.53%, versus a Downwardly-Revised Second-Quarter of 2.28% (Previously 2.89%) • Better-Quality Economic Measures Continue to Show No Full Recovery from the Collapse into 2009 and No Economic Expansion • October 2017 Advance Merchandise Trade Deficit Widened Sharply, Suggesting a Potential Early Hit to Fourth-Quarter GDP • With Monthly New- and Existing-Home Sales Still Shy of Recovering Pre-Recession Highs, Respectively by 50.7% (-50.7%) and 24.6% (-24.6%), Six-Month Smoothed Home Sales Continued in Low-Level, Faltering Stagnation  More ...
No. 922: October 2017 New Orders for Durable Goods, Existing-Home Sales Subscription required November 22nd, 2017
• Market Irrationality and Vulnerability Amidst Expectations for a Booming Economy in 2018 • Hurricane-Disruptions Boosted Recent Headline Economic Activity, With Continued Upside Impact on October 2017 Durable Goods Orders • Nonetheless, Orders Contracted Both Before and After Consideration of Inflation and Volatile Commercial Aircraft Orders • Real Orders Remained Down by 11.6% (-11.6%) from Recovering Pre-Recession Peak • Monthly Gain of 2.0% in October Existing-Home Sales Included a Downside Revision to September Activity and Some Hurricane Recovery, Along With a Year-to-Year Sales Decline of 0.9% (-0.9%) • With Monthly Activity Still Shy of Recovering Its Pre-Recession High by 24.6% (-24.6%), Smoothed Existing-Home Sales Continued in Low-Level, Faltering Stagnation  More ...
No. 921: October 2017 Industrial Production, New Residential Construction Subscription required November 17th, 2017
• Hurricane-Boosted October 2017 Industrial Production Recovered Its 2007 Pre-Recession High for a Second Time, At Least Briefly • Nonrecurring Surge in Headline Production Growth Ranged from a Return to Normal Operations to the Manufacturing of Replacements for Storm-Damaged Automobiles • Showing a Record 118 Months of Continuous Non-Expansion, the Dominant Manufacturing Sector of Production Remained Shy of Recovering Its Pre-Recession Peak by 4.7% (-4.7%) • Regularly-Volatile Housing Starts and Building Permits Surged in October, Including Some Temporary Hurricane-Driven Boost • Housing Starts Are Shy of Recovering Their Pre-Recession High by 43.2% (-43.2%), Building Permits Still Are Shy by 42.7% (-42.7%)  More ...
No. 920: October 2017 Retail Sales, Consumer and Produce Price Indices Subscription required November 15th, 2017
• Outlook for U.S. Economic and Financial-Market Activity Continues to Darken • That Former Malarial Swamp on the Potomac Offers a Tax Bill Penalizing U.S. Tax Payers with the First Formal Use of the Chained-CPI-U • Unwinding Hurricane Impact Softened October CPI Inflation • October CPI-U Monthly Inflation Slowed to 0.11% (Was 0.55%) Pulling Annual CPI-U Inflation Lower to 2.04% (Was 2.23%), with CPI-W at 2.05% (Was 2.31%) and ShadowStats at 9.8% (Was 10.0%) • A Nonsense October PPI Surge Was Due to Collapsing Gasoline Prices • October 2017 Final-Demand PPI Inflation Monthly Gain of 0.44% Pulled Annual Gain to a 69-Month High of 2.79%, from 2.62% in September 2017 • Unrevised Real Average Weekly Earnings Declined Minimally in Third-Quarter, on Early Track for a Meaningful Fourth-Quarter 2017 Contraction • Storm Impact Still Boosted October Retail Sales, While Long-Range, Non-Recovering and Downtrending Economic Trends Remained in Play •  More ...
No. 919-B October 2017 Employment and Unemployment Reporting Subscription required November 6th, 2017
• Unwinding Hurricane Impact Generated Some Nonsense October Labor Reporting; Payroll Survey Appears to Have Settled Back into Its Regular Patterns of Upside Biases, but Household Survey (Unemployment) May Not Stabilize Before December Revisions • Payroll Jobs Jumped 261,000, Household Survey Employment Plunged 484,000 (-484,000) • Headline U.3 Unemployment Fell to 17-Year Low of 4.1%, in the Context of Deteriorating Health in Key Employment Indicators • Plunging Counts of Both Unemployed and Employed Generated an Extreme and Unusual Decline of 765,000 (-765,000) in the Labor Force • Meaningless Declines in Headline October 2017 Unemployment Rates: U.3 Fell to 4.07% versus 4.22%, U.6 Fell to 7.91% versus 8.29%, and the ShadowStats-Alternate Fell to 21.6% versus 21.9% • Plunging Participation Rate and Employment-to-Population Ratio Traditionally Would Concern Fed Chair Janet Yellen  More ...
No.919-A: Latest Employment, Trade, Construction Spending, Freight Index and M3 Subscription required November 3rd, 2017
• Nonsense Employment and Unemployment Numbers from Unwinding Hurricane Impact: Payroll Employment Jumped 261,000, Household Survey Employment Dropped 484,000 (-484,000); Headline Unemployment Rate Fell to 4.1%, Because Labor Force Shrank by 765,000 (-765,000) • Meaningless Declines in October 2017 Unemployment Rates: U.3 Fell to 4.07% versus 4.22%, U.6 Fell to 7.91% versus 8.29%, and the ShadowStats-Alternate Fell to 21.6% versus 21.9% • Plunging Participation Rate and Employment-Population Ratio • Private Surveying of October Labor Conditions Signaled Continued Downturn • September Freight Index Showed Ongoing Economic Downturn and Non-Recovery • Trailing Four Quarters of Real Trade Deficit through Third-Quarter 2017: Worst in a Decade • Annual and Quarterly Declines in September 2017 Real Construction Spending Continued in a Manner Last Seen During the 2006 Housing Collapse • New Fed Chairman Will Face the Same Banking-System and Economic Challenges that Befuddled the Yellen/Bernanke Chairmanships • Annual Growth in October Money Supply M3 Jumped to 4.8% from 4.3% in September  More ...
No. 918-B :First Estimate of Third-Quarter 2017 GDP, Economic and Financial Outlook Subscription required October 30th, 2017
• Watch For Unexpected Headline Economic Weakness as Artificially Strong Numbers Reverse, with Hurricane Boosts Beginning to Unwind • Natural-Disaster-Scrambled Data Suggest Looming, Major Revisions A New Fed Chairman Will Face the Same Banking-System and Economic Challenges that Befuddled the Yellen/Bernanke Chairmanships • First Estimate of Third-Quarter 2017 GDP Growth Was 2.99% Versus 3.06% in Second-Quarter, 1.24% in First-Quarter • Third-Quarter 2017 Final Sales Growth (GDP Net of Inventories) Was 2.26% Versus 2.94% in Second-Quarter, 2.70% in First-Quarter • Headline GDP Details Did Not Make Sense in Terms of Underlying Series • Better-Quality Economic Measures Continue to Show No Full Recovery from the Collapse into 2009 and No Economic Expansion, with Stagnant Real-World Activity Increasingly Indicating a Renewed, Deepening Downturn  More ...
No. 918-A: First Estimate of Third-Quarter 2017 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) Subscription required October 27th, 2017
• First Estimate of Third-Quarter 2017 GDP Growth Was 2.99% Versus 3.06% in Second-Quarter, 1.24% in First-Quarter • Third-Quarter 2017 Final Sales Growth (GDP Net of Inventories) Was 2.26% Versus 2.94% in Second-Quarter, 2.70% in First-Quarter • No GDP Hurricane-Impact Was Discussed by the Issuing Bureau of Economic Analysis • Headline Details Do Not Make Sense in Terms of Underlying Series • Natural-Disaster-Scrambled Data Suggest Major Revisions Loom for Recent Headline Data, Ranging from Retail Sales to the GDP • Better-Quality Economic Measures Continue to Show No Full Recovery from the Collapse into 2009 and No Economic Expansion, with Stagnant Real-World Activity Increasingly Indicating a Renewed, Deepening Downturn  More ...
Archives
Have you ever wondered why the CPI, GDP and employment numbers run counter to your personal and business experiences? The problem lies in biased and often-manipulated government reporting.
Primers on Government Economic Reports What you've suspected but were afraid to ask. The story behind unemployment, the Federal Deficit, CPI, GDP.
Specialized Economic Consulting

Services include customized forecasts and analyses of the general economy, presentations and consultations in-house for clients. Contact us to discuss your needs.

John Williams'
"Shadow Government Statistics"

johnwilliams@shadowstats.com
Tel: (415) 512-7701

John Williams
PO Box 2538
Petaluma CA, 94953-2538
Some Biographical & Additional Background Information

Walter J. "John" Williams was born in 1949. He received an A.B. in Economics, cum laude, from Dartmouth College in 1971, and was awarded a M.B.A. from Dartmouth's Amos Tuck School of Business Administration in 1972, where he was named an Edward Tuck Scholar. During his career as a consulting economist, John has worked with individuals as well as Fortune 500 companies.

Although I am known formally as Walter J. Williams, my friends call me “John.” For 30 years, I have been a private consulting economist and, out of necessity, had to become a specialist in government economic reporting.

One of my early clients was a large manufacturer of commercial airplanes, who had developed an econometric model for predicting revenue passenger miles. The level of revenue passenger miles was their primary sales forecasting tool, and the model was heavily dependent on the GNP (now GDP) as reported by the Department of Commerce.  Suddenly, their model stopped working, and they asked me if I could fix it. I realized the GNP numbers were faulty, corrected them for my client (official reporting was similarly revised a couple of years later) and the model worked again, at least for a while, until GNP methodological changes eventually made the underlying data worthless.

That began a lengthy process of exploring the history and nature of economic reporting and in interviewing key people involved in the process from the early days of government reporting through the present. For a number of years I conducted surveys among business economists as to the quality of government statistics (the vast majority thought it was pretty bad), and my results led to front page stories in 1989 in the New York Times and Investors Daily (now Investors Business Daily), considerable coverage in the broadcast media and a joint meeting with representatives of all the government's statistical agencies.  

Nonetheless, the quality of government reporting has deteriorated sharply in the last couple of decades. Reporting problems have included methodological changes to economic reporting that have pushed headline economic and inflation results out of the realm of real-world or common experience.

Over the decades, well in excess of 1,000 presentations have been given on the economic outlook, or on approaches to analyzing economic data, to clients—large and small—including talks with members of the business, banking, government, press, academic, brokerage and investment communities. I also have provided testimony before Congress (details here).

An old friend—the late-Doug Gillespie—asked me some years back to write a series of articles on the quality of government statistics.  The response to those writings (the Primer Series available at the top-center of this page) was so strong that we started ShadowStats.com (Shadow Government Statistics) in 2004.  The newsletter is published as part of my economic consulting services. — John Williams

 


This material is provided under the ShadowStats.com Terms of Use. Use of this material constitutes agreement to those terms.
Privacy Policy |  Contact Us 
Copyright 2003-2017. Shadow Government Statistics, American Business Analytics & Research LLC.