John Williams'
Shadow Government Statistics
Analysis Behind and Beyond Government Economic Reporting
Gillespie Research Archives

An Examination of the March Trade Data   - May. 11, 2005


Summary

Earlier today, the Commerce Department reported that the nation's trade deficit in March came in at 55.0 billion, down sharply from February's revised deficit of $60.6 billion.
_____

Based on the Commerce Department's report of earlier today, the US trade deficit (goods and services) came in at $55.0 billion in March, compared with a revised February deficit of $60.6 billion. (The February figure was originally reported at a negative $61.0 billion.)

The March result was far below a consensus forecast that was looking for a deficit of about $62 billion.

Despite the downward revision, February's shortfall remains the monthly record, surpassing November 2004's then-record of $59.4 billion.

The trade deficit for 2005's first three months exceeded last year's January-March red ink by a very substantial $45.22 billion, or 35.1%.
                       2005       2004   Yr./Yr.
                     -------    -------  -------
        March       $ 54.986   $ 47.128   16.7%
        February    $ 60.570   $ 45.863   32.1%
        January     $ 58.504   $ 45.847   27.6%
                     -------    -------   -----
        1st Quart.  $174.060   $128.838   35.1%
                     -------    -------   -----
March's trade deficit was the result of imports totaling $157.19 billion, and record exports totaling $102.21 billion. These figures compared with respective revised import/export figures for February of $161.25 billion (a record), and $100.68 billion. Thus, in comparing March to February, imports fell about 2.5% (despite a substantial increase in oil imports), while exports rose more than 1.5%.

The net export result is one of six major components of gross domestic product. The lower-than-expected deficit in March, coupled with February's modest downward revision, will likely account for a positive impact on first-quarter GDP as it relates to the trade influence, when the next GDP estimate is released at the end of May.

As the table below indicates, March crude oil imports totaled $13.41 billion, almost $2.5 billion more than February's $10.92 billion. The increase was the result of higher import volume (+9.8%) and a large jump in price, to $41.14 per barrel in March, up from $36.85 per barrel in February.

Crude oil imports were equal to 8.5% of total imports in March, up from 6.8% in February. In March, crude imports were equal to 10.2% of goods-only imports, which were reported at $131.5 billion.

(NOTE: The above calculations take license with mixing seasonally adjusted and seasonally unadjusted data. For the purpose at hand, the distortion in not significant.)

During 2004, crude oil imports totaled $131.7 billion, about 7.5% of total imports. Of goods-only imports for the twelve-month period ($1473.1 billion), crude imports equaled 8.9%. (Again, these calculations mix seasonally adjusted and seasonally unadjusted data).
-----------------------------------------------
   TOTAL U.S. IMPORTS AND CRUDE OIL IMPORTS*
-----------------------------------------------
                   Crude Oil Imports**
        Total    -----------------------
       Imports#  Barrels  Value   Avg.   Crude/
Year/  --------  --------------  Price   Total
Month   (Amounts in Billions)   Per Bbl.  (%)
-----------------------------------------------
2005
Mar.  $ 157.191  0.326 $ 13.410  $41.14    8.5
Feb.  $ 161.250  0.297 $ 10.942   36.85    6.8
Jan.    158.937  0.323   11.410   35.35    7.2
-----------------------------------------------
2005
S/T   $ 477.378  0.946 $ 35.762  $37.80    7.0
===============================================
2004
Dec.  $ 156.169  0.321 $ 11.760  $36.63    7.5
Nov.    156.738  0.326   13.435   41.15    8.6
Oct.    154.028  0.316   13.198   41.79    8.6
Sep.    148.796  0.304   11.421   37.62    7.7
Aug.    150.397  0.331   12.044   36.37    8.0
July    146.760  0.319   10.611   33.28    7.2
June    148.542  0.347   11.697   33.76    7.9
May     144.393  0.316   10.474   33.12    7.3
Apr.    142.973  0.312    9.668   31.00    6.8
Mar.    142.531  0.332   10.162   30.64    7.1
Feb.    138.293  0.288    8.395   29.17    6.1
Jan.    134.633  0.309    8.835   28.55    6.6
-----------------------------------------------
2004
Total $1764.243  3.821 $131.700  $34.47    7.5
===============================================
2003  $1517.011  3.676  $99.167  $26.98    6.5
1998   1098.363  3.243   37.252   11.49    3.4
1993    713.058  2.543   38.469   15.13    5.4
1988    545.715  1.888   25.844   13.69    4.7
1983    323.874  1.294   38.184   29.51   11.8
1978    208.191  2.392   32.140   13.43   15.4
1973     89.342  1.393    4.593    3.30    5.1
-----------------------------------------------
  *Source: US Department of Commerce. **Not
  seasonally adjusted.  #Goods and services,
  seasonally adjusted. MEMO ITEM: Crude oil
  to goods-only imports: 1973 = 6.5%, 2004
  = 8.9%, March 2005 = 10.2%.
-----------------------------------------------
Employing the figures in the above tables, here's another way of assessing oil imports within the context of the nation's trade deficit (in approximate terms, because of the mixing of adjusted and unadjusted data). What would the deficit look like if the United States neither imported nor exported any crude oil?

In March, the goods-and-services deficit came in at $55.0 billion. With no US crude oil imports, the figure would have been $41.6 billion, or 24.4% lower.

For 2005's first three months, the goods-and-services deficit came in at $174.1 billion. With no US crude oil imports, the figure would have been $138.3 billion, or 20.6% lower.

During 2004, zero oil imports would have lowered the cumulative deficit by $131.7 billion, or by about 21.3%.
--------------------------------
 U.S. TRADE DEFICIT BY SELECTED
  COUNTRIES/REGIONS (Ranked in
  Order of March Size. Amounts
    in Billions of $s and Are
    Not Seasonally Adjusted)
--------------------------------
               2005       2005
  Country/  --------------------
   Region     March    February    
--------------------------------
  China      12.904     13.871
  Japan       7.834      6.867
  OPEC        6.584      6.255
  Canada      5.047      5.769r
  Germany     4.309      3.674
  Mexico      4.258      3.668
  Italy       1.577      1.317
  Korea       1.345      1.187
  UK          0.866      0.582
  Taiwan      0.748      1.035
--------------------------------


--------------------------------------------------------- U.S. TRADE DEFICIT BY SELECTED COUNTRIES/REGIONS (Ranked in Order of Cumulative 2004 Size. Amounts Are in Billions of $s and Are Not Seasonally Adjusted) --------------------------------------------------------- 2004 2003 % Chg. Country/ ------------------- ------------------- 2004/ Region December Cumulative December Cumulative 2003 -------------------------------------------------------- China 14.264 161.978 9.883 124.068 30.6 Japan 6.850 75.195 5.760 66.032 13.9 OPEC 5.816 71.867 4.568 51.065 40.7 Canada 4.853 65.764 4.520 51.671 27.3 Germany 4.246 45.855 4.131 39.209 17.0 Mexico 3.399 45.068 3.113 40.648 10.9 Korea 1.342 19.829 1.416 13.157 50.7 Italy 1.697 17.378 1.355 14.854 17.0 Taiwan 0.638 12.887 0.851 14.152 -8.9 UK 1.279 10.442 1.094 8.967 16.4 --------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer
Copyright 2003-2006. Gillespie Research Associates.
website by
Non-Routine Solutions