John Williams'
Shadow Government Statistics
Analysis Behind and Beyond Government Economic Reporting
Gillespie Research Archives

Another Look at May Trade Data (#2)   - Jul. 14, 2005


Summary

Yesterday morning, the Commerce Department reported that the May trade deficit came in at $55.3 billion. This compared with a revised April deficit of $56.9. Overall, the May results look a little "funny," as in better than they should have been. Perhaps the Commerce Department is getting a head start on "massaging" second-quarter GDP a little?
_____

The May trade deficit (goods and services) came in at $55.3 billion, down $1.6 billion from April's revised shortfall of $56.9 billion (originally reported at minus $57.0 billion). The consensus forecast for May was contemplating red ink of something around $57.0 billion, a result that, frankly, was more in line with reality than the one actually released.

May's reported deficit was the result of imports of $162.2 billion, and exports of $106.9 billion This compared with a revised import/export result for April of $163.6 and $106.7 billion.

The Numbers in General

Based on the Commerce Department's report of yesterday, the US trade deficit (goods and services) came in at $57.0 billion in May, compared with a revised April deficit of $53.6 billion. (The April figure was originally reported at a negative $57.0 billion.)

February 2005's shortfall of $60.1 billion remains the monthly record. November 2004's $59.0 billion presently holds down second place.

The trade deficit for 2005's first five months exceeded last year's January-May red ink by a substantial $48.0 billion, or 20.3%.
                         2005       2004     Y/Y
                       -------    -------  -------
        May           $ 55.349   $ 48.742   13.6%
        April         $ 56.899   $ 48.406   17.5%
                      --------   --------   -----
         Subtotal     $112.248   $ 97.148   15.5%
                      --------   --------   -----
        March         $ 53.562   $ 46.966   14.0%
        February      $ 60.117   $ 45.834   31.2%
        January       $ 58.077   $ 46.053   26.1%
                      --------   --------   -----
        1st Quart.    $171.756   $138.853   23.7%
                      --------   --------   -----
        Year to Date  $284.004   $236.001   20.3%
                      ========   ========   =====
May's trade deficit was the result of imports totaling $162.24 billion, and record exports totaling $106.89 billion. These figures compared with respective revised import/export figures for April of $163.64 billion and $106.74 billion. Thus, in comparing May to April, imports fell $1.40 billion or 0.9%; exports rose $0.15 billion or bit more than 0.1%.

The net export result is one of six major components of gross domestic product. The April and May monthly average, which will be used to calculate the "advance" estimate of second-quarter GDP to be released on 7/29, was $56.12 billion. This compared with a monthly average of $57.25 during the first quarter. Thus, quarter over quarter, the trade component is likely to provide a modest boost to the Commerce Department's initial rendering of GDP.

The Crude Oil Data

As the table below indicates, May crude oil imports totaled $13.73 billion, $0.32 billion less than April's $14.05 billion. The decrease was the net result of a small increase in import volume (+1.6%), accompanied by a 3.8% decline in price ($43.08 per barrel in May, versus $44.76 per barrel in April).

Crude oil imports were equal to 8.4% of total imports in May, down from 8.6% in April. In May, crude imports were equal to 10.1% of goods-only imports, which were reported at $135.3 billion.

(NOTE: The above calculations take license with mixing seasonally adjusted and seasonally unadjusted data. For the purpose at hand, the distortion in not significant.)

During 2005's first five months, crude oil imports totaled 1.579 billion barrels, valued at $63.5 billion. (This was equal to about 7.9% of total imports. Of goods-only imports for this five-month period [$672.3 billion], crude imports equaled 9.5%.)

By comparison, during 2004's first five months, crude oil imports totaled 1.558 billion barrels, only modestly lower than 2005 volume. However, owing to increasing prices, 2005's five-month cost exceeded last year's by a very substantial $15.9 billion, or 33.4%.

For all of 2004, crude oil imports totaled $131.7 billion, about 7.5% of total imports. Of goods-only imports for the twelve-month period ($1472.9 billion), crude imports equaled 8.9%. (Again, these calculations mix seasonally adjusted and seasonally unadjusted data).
-----------------------------------------------
   TOTAL U.S. IMPORTS AND CRUDE OIL IMPORTS*
-----------------------------------------------
                   Crude Oil Imports**
        Total    -----------------------
       Imports#  Barrels  Value   Avg.   Crude/
Year/  --------  --------------  Price   Total
Month   (Amounts in Billions)   Per Bbl.  (%)
-----------------------------------------------
2005
May   $ 163.241  0.319 $ 13.726  $43.08    8.4
Apr.    163.640  0.314   14.045   44.76    8.6
Mar.    156.914  0.326   13.410   41.14    8.5 
Feb.    161.877  0.297   10.942   36.85    6.8
Jan.    160.656  0.323   11.410   35.55    7.1
-----------------------------------------------
2005
S/T   $ 806.328  1.579 $ 63.533  $40.24    7.9
===============================================
2004
Dec.  $ 156.393  0.321 $ 11.689  $36.46    7.5
Nov.    157.618  0.330   13.577   41.19    8.6
Oct.    154.098  0.313   13.107   41.84    8.5
Sep.    149.607  0.297   11.143   37.52    7.5
Aug.    150.705  0.334   12.196   36.54    8.1
July    147.523  0.324   10.818   33.38    7.3
June    149.143  0.345   11.631   33.74    7.8
May     145.141  0.318   10.535   33.14    7.3
Apr.    142.857  0.312    9.662   31.00    6.8
Mar.    142.139  0.330   10.118   30.66    7.1
Feb.    138.223  0.288    8.414   29.17    6.1
Jan.    135.584  0.310    8.853   28.57    6.5
-----------------------------------------------
2004
Total $1769.031  3.822 $131.743  $34.47    7.5
===============================================
2003  $1517.011  3.676  $99.167  $26.98    6.5
1998   1098.363  3.243   37.252   11.49    3.4
1993    713.058  2.543   38.469   15.13    5.4
1988    545.715  1.888   25.844   13.69    4.7
1983    323.874  1.294   38.184   29.51   11.8
1978    208.191  2.392   32.140   13.43   15.4
1973     89.342  1.393    4.593    3.30    5.1
-----------------------------------------------
  *Source: US Department of Commerce. **Not
  seasonally adjusted.  #Goods and services,
  seasonally adjusted. MEMO ITEM: Crude oil
  to goods-only imports: 1973 = 6.5%, 2004
  = 8.9%, May 2005 = 10.1%.
-----------------------------------------------
What would the deficit look like if the United States neither imported nor exported any crude oil?

Employing the figures in the above tables (remembering there is the mixing of seasonally adjusted and unadjusted data), in the absence of oil imports, the May deficit would have come in at $41.6 billion, $13.7 billion or 24.8% lower than the reported $55.3 billion.

For 2005's first five months, the deficit came in at $284.0 billion. With no US crude oil imports, the figure would have been $220.5 billion, or 22.4% less.

During 2004, zero oil imports would have lowered the year's deficit by $131.7 billion, or by about 21.3%.

Some Venues in Which the Deficit is Being Created
--------------------------------
 U.S. TRADE DEFICIT BY SELECTED
  COUNTRIES/REGIONS (Ranked in
   Order of May Size. Amounts
    in Billions of $s and Are
    Not Seasonally Adjusted)
--------------------------------
               2005       2005
  Country/  --------------------
   Region      May       April
--------------------------------
  China      15.754     14.715
  OPEC        7.268      7.060
  Japan       6.583      7.177
  Canada      4.754      5.403
  Germany     4.493      4.033
  Mexico      4.476      4.400
  Italy       1.678      1.479
  Korea       1.502      1.301
  Taiwan      0.873      0.740
  Russia      0.781      1.417
  UK          0.631      0.848
--------------------------------


--------------------------------------------------------- U.S. TRADE DEFICIT BY SELECTED COUNTRIES/REGIONS (Ranked in Order of 2005 Size. Amounts Are in Billions of $s and Are Not Seasonally Adjusted) --------------------------------------------------------- 2005 % Change Country/ Through --------- Region May-a Annual-b 2004 2003 2004/2003 --------------------------------------------------------- China 74.499 173.998 161.938 124.068 30.5 Japan 34.671 83.210 75.562 66.032 14.4 OPEC 33.219 79.726 71.843 51.065 40.7 Canada 27.224 65.338 66.480 51.671 28.7 Germany 20.056 48.134 45.850 39.281 16.7 Mexico 19.711 47.306 45.067 40.648 10.9 Italy 7.512 18.029 17.413 14.854 17.2 Korea 7.197 17.273 19.756 13.157 50.2 Russia 4.978 11.947 8.930 6.171 44.7 Taiwan 4.568 10.963 12.879 14.152 -9.0 UK 3.681 8.834 10.274 8.967 14.6 -------------------------------------------------------- a = actual 2005 cumulative. b = annualized. --------------------------------------------------------


Disclaimer
Copyright 2003-2006. Gillespie Research Associates.
website by
Non-Routine Solutions